The background to this project, carried out by Social Anthropologist Maryon McDonald, stemmed from reflection on the growing analytical interest in the body in the social sciences during the latter half of the twentieth century. Initially, this interest seemed to mean a shift from the body as a taken-for-granted aspect of life to the body as explicit object, apparently singular and available for study. However, as social studies of “the body” proliferated, this once singular object then analytically dissolved and the relationalities and realities involved have multiplied.
To look more carefully at these themes, a series of workshops was launched in conjunction with the Royal Anthropological Institute, the first two of which, on "Genomics" (April 2005) and "Social Bodies" (September 2005), have expressed the approach to be taken here. Maryon McDonald then convened another conference on "Anatomy in context" was held in Cambridge in September 2007, setting out some of her first year’s findings and bringing together anthropologists, anatomists and historians of science. The project starts from the anthropological understanding that "bodies" are inherently social or relational - just as the sciences that helped to construct an apparently singular "human body" have themselves been accorded an inherent sociality. At the same time, the bio-sciences that once kept the "social" at bay appear to have been called to account and the space of the social has been re-constructed as bioethics and ethics. With developments such as bio-banks, transplants, stem cell medicine and genomics, for example, the initial idea for this project was to investigate new experiential realities of bodies and the emergent forms of the social, in the practical imaginations of governance and accountability, that accompany them. It is the realities of all this, in new bodies as working objects and the embodied knowledge they effect, that remain of central interest here.
For this project, 2007 and 2008 have been largely devoted to fieldwork. Maryon McDonald’s Social Anthropology project has involved carrying out ethnographic fieldwork in two different contexts: the teaching and learning of anatomy in a dissection room, and then a study of the professional practices of organ transplantation. It is this second aspect of the work that has occupied the entirety of 2008. The study of the teaching of anatomy meant looking at the bodies that students learn about and acquire during part of their medical education, and the study of organ transplantation involves a closer examination of such bodies and their congruence or disjunction with each other and with the bodies of the medical practitioners themselves. At the same time, whilst all these bodies could be said to be necessarily social, the shape of the social in self-consciously "ethical" practice has become very much a part of the project.
The second part of the field research has already involved - in April 2008 - presenting some initial feedback to the transplant community studied, and McDonald also managed during 2008 to continue to participate in discussion at important conferences at both national and EU levels (see publications/presentations). As a result of her work to date, McDonald was invited last year to become a member of a working group of "ELPAT" (the EU group dealing with "Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects of Transplantation") , to produce work of relevance for medical practitioners, donors and recipients. In November 2008, she chose to become a working member of ELPAT’s Deceased Donation working group, writing up the key issues, and focussing on topics closely linked to her field research. There will be a further meeting of ELPAT in 2009 to take stock on these topics. More details of ELPAT’s work and the presentations can be found here. |